"I have a new motto now because of you: From this situation, something good will come! You're a true godsend! I thank you from the bottom of my heart." -Jamie
Read More Testimonials»

Our Living Healthier Experts

Bob Livingstone

Bob Livingstone

LCSW and psychotherapist in private practice for almost twenty...

Shared by First30Days View Profile»
Dean Ornish

Dean Ornish

Professor of medicine and best-selling author

Shared by First30Days View Profile»
Bob Harper

Bob Harper

Fitness trainer on NBC's hit show The Biggest Loser

Shared by First30Days View Profile»

Meet all of our Diet and Fitness Experts»


The latest news on this change — carefully culled from the world wide web by our change agents. They do the surfing, so you don't have to!

The Presidential Health Debate

The Presidential Health Debate

The presidential debates are scheduled to begin tonight with a focus on economic and foreign policy. But one subject has been less of a debate and more of a question in the minds of voters: Which presidential candidate is healthy enough to sit in the Oval Office? Both candidates have released their medical histories, and here's what we know:
*Arizona Senator John McCain, Republican Nominee: If McCain is elected, his ripe old age of 72 would make him the oldest first-term president. When his 1,173-page health history was released in May, McCain’s doctors said he was in “excellent health.” The senator has suffered a bout with melanoma, a skin cancer, which he had removed from his left temple. McCain also takes a medicine for cholesterol, aspirin to thwart blood clots and medication to avert kidney stones. He smoked for 25 years, quitting in 1980. McCain often refers to his 96-year-old mother as proof that good genes run in the family.
*Illinois senator Barack Obama, Democratic Nominee: The 47-year-old quit smoking in 2007, using Nicorette gum to help ease cravings. Like his running mate, Obama’s doctors have also deemed him as being in “excellent health.” The senator is known for his penchant for basketball and water sports.

Political pundits say that a presidential candidate’s health history has become essential to the voting process. President Bill Clinton was asked to lose weight when he came into office, current President George W. Bush has admitted to early drinking problems, and Franklin Delano Roosevelt hid a history of hypertension and cardiac problems throughout his terms, dying of a cerebral hemorrhage in 1945 during his fourth term. He also had polio.
We want to know: Would a president’s state of health sway your voting decision? [The Miami Herald]

Posted: 9/26/08

This is a factor that everyone should take into consideration when voting. Although these people have the best doctors in the world and are monitored on a regular basis they are still human. Caroline makes a good point. This is where the VP slot should come into play with this topic. Who is more fit to run this Country? Biden or Palin?

  • By bcherep
  • on 9/30/08 8:39 AM EST

For me, the specific spot where a candidate's health comes into play is when I am considering his VP. In that case, if John McCain dies, am I comfortable with Sarah Palin being the president of my country? And the same goes for Obama and Biden. Health definitely plays a part when I consider the fact that I might be left with an unfit VP as my president.

On another note, lets say the president is not deceased, but frequently falling ill. If that is the case, how fit is he to be running our country? Now, I understand that there is no way to predict unfortunate health circumstances. But if some of the proof is there prior to taking office, then it is at least something to consider when hitting the polls. It may not be the sole deciding factor, but, nevertheless, it is a factor.


The problem is that anyone can have a heart attack or cancer at any time. Remember Tim Russert? He wasn't in the worst of health but his death was totally sudden. HOWEVER, you can't deny that McCain is old and has already fought cancer and quite possibly could get sick and not serve out his term. It's definitely something to consider.


Nope, probably not. Although health is important in regular life, it's not as important when it comes to political issues, in my opinion.